常識論(Common Sense)節錄 --- 僅以此篇獻給我台灣同胞
如果你關心台灣新聞, 那你一定會看到這個嚇人的數據. Google 培林從1987年以來已造成超過218,000頭豬隻死亡或生病 . 從著名的部落格主, 到各大新聞媒體, 到知名教授, 到噗浪, twitter 上到處都是根據這數據來申衍出對自己有利的說法. 這些專家,學者,名嘴,網路名人就是標準的引用未經證實的二手傳播來散播恐懼. 這數字到底從哪裡來呢? 只要 google 一下便不難發現是在 msn 上這篇 Dispute over drug in feed limiting US meat exports . 作者是 Helena Bottemiller 小姐, 她的主業是 Food Safety News , 一個專門幫消費者告食品廠的律師樓所設的網站. 該篇文章同時在(MSN例外)的幾個非主流網站(像Mother Jones)上刊登 . (舊的)本文如下 " Since it was introduced [13 years ago], ractopamine had sickened or killed more than 218,000 pigs as of March 2011, more than any other animal drug on the market, a review of FDA veterinary records shows." 這數字看起來簡直不可思議, 好像美國政府草菅人命. 於是我9天前寫了封信去問她數字出處 , 並於今天下午拿到了她的回信. (如下) Hi xxx, Thanks for your email. Sorry to be slow getting back to you. All of the documents and an explanation are now posted online here: http://thefern.org/2012/ 02/ractopamine-and-pigs- looking-at-the-numbers We recently clarified that line to say: " Since the drug was intro...
Comments